So I have been joining various Facebook groups that focus on topics regarding dieting and nutrition which represent different labels, styles and methods of eating. For example, I am in a few vegan and raw food groups as well as natural nutrition groups. What I have seen out of these groups are highly passionate people who live, breath, and believe in what they do. Their approaches to nutrition and dieting vary, but the passion remains similar.
If you have followed me long enough, you know that I focus on being natural as my fundamental approach. This is a very simple approach to apply when dealing with a vegan or raw food group. They all eat natural foods straight from mother nature for the most part. However, some topics get quite complex and far exceed my level of knowledge and understanding for now.
Ways of eating these days tend to be labeled and those who eat a certain way will be labeled one way or another. It’s like a genre of music. And then there are sub genres with eating just like there are with music. Without getting into detail, I want to move forward with the topic of this blog.
The topic of this blog was influenced recently by a discussion from a facebook group that intrigued me. It is known as Mono Eating. Mono eating consists basically of eating just one type of food for a day, a week or even months, but with switching to a new food to focus on each day, week, month etc.
Does this sound crazy or what? How and why would anyone go about eating one type of food for a day like apples or bananas? Wouldn’t you be lacking certain macro and micronutrients or even going overboard with some? This was my outlook on the subject at first glance, but as I let it settle in, I grew rather fond and curious of this type of eating. I wanted to know the why and how to this thing called mono eating.
About Mono Eating and my view on it
The Mono eating diet also shares a similar concept known as the 80/10/10 diet. This means 80% carbs, 10% fat and 10% protein. This is usually in the form of eating strictly fruit and/or starchy carb vegetables because they contain usually more carbs than fat or protein. The ratio can be changed however, in favor for a more balanced ratio which most believe is a better formula for weight loss and over all energy. This also makes me curious as to why and how the mono eating diet and 80/10/10 diet would benefit anyone in any way.
Fruits and vegetables are in favour of the mono eating approach. They resonate with the raw, vegan and/or vegetarian lifestyle. It is believed that mankind, in the early stages, had access to only few types of food, mainly fruits and some vegetables and even a specific food depending on where they lived in the world. If this is the case, they were certainly “mono eating” all the time. They ate whatever was available, since there was no trading or shipping. They would eat like apes with all the berries and bananas they had available and limited to in their dwelling on earth.
Now lets not forget about when mankind discovered meat and began to hunt animals. Our evolution has been shaped over and over through the millenniums, but it has only been until recently over the last few hundred years that trading and shipping was formed. This means variety in food has not been around and exposed to individuals for too long in our evolutionary development.
Are there Benefits to Mono Eating?
Fruits and Vegetables are superficial in the realm of nutrition with an abundance of vitamins and minerals, but the risk of deficiency and/or toxicity can occur when eating one fruit all day for days or weeks.
So what would be so beneficial or even the purpose of such a diet? From what I understand, here are a few of them:
Fasting and Detox
Fruits and vegetables are your number one source for detoxifying the body. They are low in fat and protein, high in fiber, low in calories and full of water. Though they are high in sugar, it’s all natural and sure replaces a caramel latte or a soda.
Fruits and vegetables, when eaten alone, can serve as a “cheat fast”. It’s less filling, but better than eating nothing.
Better Digestion
Eating just one type of food eliminates the confusion for your digestive system, because it only has to focus on one food type. Today, most people eat in the form of variety all the time. We spice, salt, oil and sugar coat just about everything. We eat different food groups all in one meal. We put granola in our yogurt, peanut butter on our bread, berries in our cereal, chicken in our salad and gravy on our potatoes.
Now just think of how many ingredients there are in all the processed food people eat, such as granola, bread and lunch meat. A ham sandwich is far more than just bread and ham. The ingredients that make up the bread and ham add up to many, many different ingredients in which are artificial garbage and the body does not know what to do with them. Our bodies were not designed to digest fake food and so much at once.
Just think, if you had a power saw that was made for cutting wood and you had to cut through wood, metal, tile and glass with just the one blade, you would damage it. You need to cut the wood first and then change the blade to cut metal, glass, or tile, etc. For the record, I pulled that analogy out of my ass, but you get the idea. Our digestive systems work similarly and use different enzymes to adjust for digestion of different food groups. Eating all kinds of food at once can be harmful over time to our digestive health.
To Gain Appreciation for One Food
The mono eating diet may be boring and bland, but I believe there is some value in it to a certain degree. Instead of eating a banana mixed in with oatmeal and chocolate with peanut butter, eat several bananas at once if one doesn’t satisfy you. This way, you will learn to enjoy it on it’s own without being blended in with a bunch of stuff.
I believe we neglect the opportunity to enjoy fruit and other food on their own for the most part and it just makes us want more variety as if we don’t have enough already. So maybe we should learn to go without variety to gain appreciation for food in that mother nature provides us with in isolation.
Process of Elimination
By eating one specific thing for a day, or even a meal, this will give you a better insight into how your body reacts to certain food, since they are in isolation. From there, you can better determine what makes you thrive and what makes you weak.
Now let me reason a little with this concept here. If you eat nothing but strawberries all day, you are going to be eating a whole lot of strawberries to the point where you may run into complications. For example, one serving of strawberries contain roughly our daily intake of vitamin C, so if you want to eat a sustainable amount, you are getting a dangerously high amount of vitamin C and or other things. Plus, you may get sick of whatever you are eating for days alone.
For these matters, I can understand the necessities of indulging in a mono eating diet, but certainly not something I would recommend until I have tried it myself first. Almost all of the food from mother nature has an imbalance of nutrients and therefore, a sustainable mono eating diet may be very hard to find. In fact, it can be downright dangerous if you don’t know what you are doing.
If I were to Try Mono Eating
Now lets do a nutritional rundown analysis. Assume I try mono eating for one whole week. I eat one specific food each day for seven days. For this approach, I have chosen 7 different foods (5 fruits and 2 vegetables) that I think would be the most feasible to try this out with.
Now to make this type of eating sustainable, I have set a rule of 2000 calories per day. This means each type of food needs to meet the 2000 calorie mark. How interesting this will be with just produce! Here are the 7 foods and their nutritional data along with my outlook.
APPLES
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: 1 medium apple (154g), 80 calories, 25 apples to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 25 apples: 0g of fat, 0g of sodium, 4250mg of potassium, 550g of carbs, 125g of fibre, 400g of sugar, 0g of protein, 50% DV of vitamin A, 200% DV of vitamin C, 0% DV of calcium, 50% DV of iron
Apples are missing two macronutrients, fat and protein. This is an issue and unless it’s a cleanse or a “cheat fast” apples would not sustain me for the day. 25 apples give you a high amount of potassium and more than their fair share of fibre. This may be beneficial for some aggressive cleansing, but I am skeptical on the overall intake of sugar. Even though it is natural, I am guessing 400 grams is excessive. Maybe if I ate just one meal consisting of a few apples?
AVOCADOS
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: ½ avocado (75g), 140 calories, 14 servings (8 medium avocados) to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 8 medium avocados: 182g of fat, 6020mg of potassium, 112g of carbs, 112g of fibre, 14g of sugar, 42g of protein, 28% DV of vitamin A, 140% DV of vitamin C, 14% DV of calcium, 35% DV of iron
The ultimate fat fruit is also very low in sugar and since they are high in calories, less of them are needed. Only 8 avocados to fill you for the day and the total carb count is remarkable! Very suitable for a low carb diet, but not too extreme. You also get a good amount of vitamin C. Since they are also high in potassium, you double your intake for the day. For this matter, balancing it out with some sodium is a good idea. That’s not cheating right?
Check out the protein figure. 42 grams of protein, not bad from just fruit! Overall, this is definitely something I feel more comfortable with than apples.
BANANAS
Nutrition facts: Serving size: 1 medium banana (118g), 105 calories, 20 servings to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 20 bananas: 0g of fat, 20mg of sodium, 8440mg of potassium, 540g of carbs, 60g of fibre, 280g of sugar, 25g of protein, 40% DV of vitamin A, 340% DV of vitamin C, 20% DV of calcium, 40% DV of iron
Bananas contain less potassium than avocados but require more to reach the 2000 calorie quota. Nearly triple the standard for daily potassium intake is reached along with a ton of carbs! Surprisingly, the sugar amount is not as high as I thought. You even get some protein out of the bananas for the day and a solid amount of fibre. Maybe more than necessary, but shouldn’t be harmful. You even get a triple dose of vitamin C for the day! Definitely an energy food with lots of electrolytes. Add some sea salt to balance out the charge!
BLUEBERRIES
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: 1 cup (148g), 84 calories, 24 servings to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 24 servings: 0g of fat, 24mg of sodium, 504g of carbs, 96g of fibre, 360g of sugar, 24g of protein, 48% DV of vitamin A, 576% DV of vitamin C, 24% DV of calcium, 48% DV of iron
Using 1 cup as a serving, my daily caloric intake would be reached with 24 cups. That is roughly 7 pounds of blueberries for the day. For some reason, I think I would enjoy eating this many. I could eat them all day like a gorilla! Though they must be organic. Now the problem is that there are some nutrient imbalances with this amount. 0 grams of fat, very low sodium, very high carbohydrates and sugar. The fibre intake seems to be dangerously high, along with the vitamin C. Blueberries are also very rich in antioxidants though, and vitamin C acts as an antioxidant so I will consider blueberries for the mono trial.
STRAWBERRIES
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: 1 cup (140g), 50 calories, 40 servings to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 40 servings: 20g of fat, 0g of sodium, 400g of carbs, 120g of fibre, 280g of sugar, 40g of protein, 0% DV of vitamin A, 4000% DV of vitamin C, 80% DV of calcium, 160% DV of iron
According to a similar serving size as blueberries, strawberries have less calories. This is a surprise to me since strawberries tend to have more fat and protein. Makes me wonder where all the calories are coming from in blueberries. And to equal the amount of 2000 calories, it requires 12 pounds of strawberries! That is roughly $60 worth of strawberries since I buy them organic. A regular serving of strawberries alone reaches your daily intake of vitamin C, with 40 servings (too meet quota) you are getting 40 times your daily recommendation of vitamin C! If there is a safe limit for this vitamin, I am sure we would reach the level of toxicity on this one! You actually get a fair amount of calcium and iron though, which is hard to get from fruit.
BROCCOLI
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: 1 stalk (151g), 51 calories, 40 servings to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 40 broccoli stalks: 40g of fat, 2000mg of sodium, 400g of carbs, 160g of fibre, 120g of sugar, 160g of protein, 760% DV of vitamin A, 8960% DV of vitamin C, 280% DV of calcium, 240% DV of iron
A prime example of green power right here! I just had to nominate broccoli for the mono eating trial. It is high in all sorts of vitamins and minerals, very alkaline, and even tallies up some impressive macronutrient figures! But could the massive quantity cancel out the quality time with broccoli for the day?
With one stalk as a serving size at only 51 calories, you need 40 servings and with that, comes with some serious numbers. Very high amounts of fibre and vitamin C, in fact, nearly 90 times your daily intake of vitamin C. This is rather not a surprise to me with the quantity, but what really stands out is how we end up with 40 of fat, 120g of sugar, and 160g of protein! That is astounding. That much protein along with calcium at nearly 3 times your RDA, from a more bioavailable source than dairy and meat! You also get lots of iron.
The sodium level is about perfect for the day. 1mg of sodium per calorie, but the overall sugar amount is very surprising. It adds up. High amounts of vitamin A are also important, since we lack it in much of our food. Broccoli has it all!
CARROTS
Nutrition Facts: Serving size: 1 medium carrot (61g), 25 calories, 80 carrots to reach 2000 calories. Nutrition Data for 80 carrots: 0g of fat, 3360mg of sodium, 480g of carbs, 160g of fibre, 240g of sugar, 80g of protein, 16320% DV of vitamin A, 480% DV of vitamin C, 160% DV of calcium, 80% DV of iron
Another great snack, along with broccoli, carrots are notorious for improving eyesight right? That myth would be due to the sheer abundance of vitamin A. One medium carrot contains roughly double of your daily required intake of the vitamin. Now we need 80 carrots to meet quota with our calorie intake for the day, so how much vitamin A are we talking? About 160 times your recommended daily intake! Now if my eyesight doesn’t improve after a day of eating this many carrots, I will be greatly disappointed!
No need to add salt to the orange sticks. 80 carrots a day will do you just fine if you compare it to the typical Western diet, which I don’t recommend basing that rule off of. You also get 480 grams of starchy carbs with half of it coming from sugar. Also, you get a fair amount of protein for the day. 1 gram per carrot! Calcium and iron are also on par, but the vitamin C intake may be a little too high. Dip some carrots in a whole, plain yogurt or oil for added fat and away you go!
Conclusion
Judging by the figures that I discovered with these 7 foods, I think broccoli comes out on top. It has the most stable nutrition profile, and aside from the insanely high vitamin C content, I think it would be the most promising to undergo a whole day of just one food.
Avocados are right up there as well. They are low in sugar, carbs, and are very alkaline like broccoli. If your not afraid of all of the extra fat, this would be an excellent choice to leave you with for a day.
What I would really like to do instead of going sheer mono for one day is take these 7 foods and have one whole meal of each for the day. This way, I will avoid toxicity or deficiency of any vitamin or mineral and get an adequate amount from a variety of thriving foods. I know this is technically not mono eating, but I think it is a safe and fun thing to try. I will have to research more on vitamin and mineral deficiency and toxicity before I try an actual day of eating just one of these 7 foods.
There are also many other vitamins and minerals in these 7 foods not listed that I have to consider as well.
Your Thoughts
I would like to know your thoughts and suggestions on this topic as well as what type of food would you go with if you had to pick something specific for the day. Your input can also help me base a more informed decision on this.
Thank you for reading and share away your comments!
Brendan Kearney
Vibranatural
http://www.vibranatural.com
https://www.facebook.com/vibranaturalfit
http://www.twitter.com/vibranatural1